I’ve played the NBA Live and NBA 2K series simulators and I feel like the gameplay is smoother and more realistic in 2K. Both games have amazing graphics so if you’re just interested in how it looks you can’t go wrong either way. I’m just not a fan of the gameplay in NBA Live because it is somewhat unrealistic… at least in the last one I played which was 07 I think. Players with “powers” like good at dunking and good at passing and all didn’t seem right. I know a bunch of people that are fans of the NBA Live series, though so I think its just a matter of preference.

and randolph hasn’t played a game.. but he has a chance to be that guy. Jackson on some nights can do everything.. score, distribute, defend, rebound, but sometimes he is sloppy and he is a streaky player. Al Harrington has a very good skill set but he just doesn’t produce. So i would have to go with monta.

NBA 2k series kills Live. i was kind of dissapointed with last year’s 2k for ps3 but it still was a good game and the last good NBA live was 2003. after that it went so down hill it isn’t even funny. absolute garbage.

Baron Davis said it himself when he was here, Ellis has the most talent of any Warrior.

2k series, hands down. Always have been, always will be. Simply better in all aspects.

You’ve got to put Maggette in this lineup. The guy shoots decent from 3, can rebound, take the ball to the hoop, hit freethrows, and defend with anyone on the warriors. Not to mention he is in peak physical shape, so forget about him getting tired towards the end of the season (yeah I’m talkin to you Stephen Jackson). I vote for Maggette

All around game. There is really only one Warrior with an all around game when taking into account things like D and 3’s. Jack. Everyone else is pretty suspect on D with the exception of Buike Biedrins Turiaf and Wright. But all those guys except Buike are pretty awful 3 shooters. If you"re talking all around players Maggette should be there but definitely not AR and I dont know about Monta, if his D is better this year than yeah he should be. Biedrins is the best at fg% i and one of the best on D, and will be better this year, but you can’t put a center there or even a pf unless its someone like Rasheed Wallace. So its limited to guards, and when talking about all around guards on the Warriors the list should come down to Jackson Maggette Monta and Azabuike. And you gotta give Jack the edge

Fun post to think about though

josh smith

i think Buike has the best all around game. he has more handles than Monta, can lock down on a player pretty well, has the 3pt range, has the athletic ability for offense and defense (ask JR Smith), has decent court vision and rebounding ability for his size. he’s a bit overlooked for his all around game at times. once he gets more playing time and shows his game, people are going to be glad we re-signed him at a bit of a discount for 3 yrs.